Stats & writing sample & schools applied to

一共就那么点人…愿意分享信息的看一遍基本都记住了 :rofl:祝前辈好运~话说SFU中国人不少啊 :yum:

1 Like

Calgary离落基山脉那么近,风景一定很好!!
从Calgary到温哥华自驾游一定很好玩!!(手动星星眼!)

2 Likes

您好!~想问问如果申请Oxford Bphil,有什么需要特别注意的事项吗?目前我正在准备申请,在修改ws,ws是关于康德CPR的一篇文章。

怎么今年没人放结果了啊

背景:国内本硕
本科:文科混合项目(主哲学)
硕士:哲学
GRE:160+168+3.0(只交了4个学校)
TOEFL:105(speaking 23; writing 24)
Writing Sample: Egalitarianism
Letter writers: 硕士导师、硕士本专业老师、上过一门课的外教、另一所学校的读书会老师

Programs applied to (All PhD):
美国: Rice, PSU, Northwestern, UWM, UCB, UoPenn, UIUC, Arizona, Yale, UW, NYU, UCSD, Virginia, Mizzou, Rutgers, Notre Dame
加拿大: McGill
英国: Manchester
Accepted, Waitlisted, Rejected, Pending

9 Likes

背景:国内本硕
本科:城市规划 GPA 3.40
硕士:哲学 GPA 89.3/100
GRE:V163+Q168+AW4.0
TOEFL:105(speaking 21 QAQ)
Writing Sample: The Boydian Package and the Reference Change for “Good”
Letter writers: 硕士导师(科学哲学)、硕士老师(形而上学和逻辑哲学)*2,不过两封是自己写的老师修改,一个是老师写的

Programs applied to (不知道咋调颜色TAT):
Rejected: UWSTL, UWM, Maryland, Arizona state, Duke, Colorado, Brown, Arizona, UCLA, UCSD, Pittsburgh, UNC, UTA, USC, MIT, UMass, Rutgers, Florida state,
Accepted: Syracuse

MA programs applied to:
Rejected: Virginia tech, TTU
Accepted: Western Michigan

3.1 收到Syracuse的waitlist
3.3 VT 无了,UMass看起来也无了,感觉自己还是各方面都太弱了 :sob:
3.9 和已注销同学一样,都拿了ND的second waitlist。感觉ND的这个操作不是很厚道 :sweat_smile:
3.10 western michigan waitlisted。求求来一个录取吧,心里好没底啊,感觉已经在失学的边缘了。
3.30 Syracuse的virtual meeting,和大家聊了一下,感觉教授和学生们都很不错~
4.3 收到Rochester的邮件,说是再有两个人decline offer就可以给转正了。但是希望并不是很大。
4.6 收到了WMU的邮件,update了一下说马上要开始给WL转正了,现在的想法是WMU给了offer的话就直接接受了,不管两所phd的wl了
4.16 收到了WMU和Syracuse的offer。想来想去,感觉自己基础太薄弱,或许再花点时间拓展一下AOI并且接受一点合格的哲学训练是一件很好的事情,最终还是decline了Syracuse,接受了WMU!

12 Likes

背景:澳洲本科
GRE:161+170+3.5
GPA: 本科 Second Class Honors; 交换 4.0/4.0
Writing Sample: Metaphysics; Causation; Responsibility
Letter writers: Supervisor;本校的教授;交换的教授
AOI: Metaphysics; Philosophy of science

Programs applied to:

PhD: Rutgers, UMass, UVA, Syracuse.

MA: NIU, USI, UH, SFU, UWM, Tufts, Calgary, Virginia Tech.

|Accepted, Rejected, Pending|

2.8 NIU Admitted
2.25 SFU Rejected 最想去的MA没了😭
3.3 VT Rejected; UMass Rejected. Virginia Waitlisted.
3.15 Calgary waitlisted; UWM waitlisted
3.16 Tufts rejected
4.1 Vriginia rejected
4.4 USI admitted
4.5 withdraw了UWM和Calgary的waitlist。

想了很久NIU还是USI,现在应该是去USI了,有一起的小伙伴吗0.0

4.9 收到了Houston的offer,funding waitlist. 我当时催推荐信联系教授太多次了,后来教授这个项目忘交了,我也不想联系了想着算了,没想到少一个推荐信还是有。
4.10 拒绝了NIU 有钱Houston 没钱USI
4.16 Houston没有轮上,去USI了!Nice try, Houston!

9 Likes

国内本
GPA: 3.67 (Cumulative); 3.89 (Philosophy)
IELTS:8
GRE:考了感觉不够高没有交…

Writing Sample:
长论文:语言哲学语用学相关,双倍行距18页
短论文:柏拉图政治哲学相关,双倍行距6页

AOI:phillanguage, philmind, philscience(在ps里写的interests和推荐人选择差别很大…毕设是心灵哲学和科学哲学的交叉但philmind大四才修,科哲的老师不太熟orz )

Letter writers:
#1 语言哲学外教(Assistant prof,也是WS的指导和毕业论文导师)
#2 政治哲学教授(Prof,大三下政治哲学课老师)
#3 美学教授(Assistant prof,专业实习带队老师)

Programs applied to (All MA):
Northern Illinois, Texas Tech (off waitlist) , Western Michigan (declined), Calgary (withdrawn), Alberta (off waitlist and declined), McMaster, CEU (declined), USI (declined)

2.6 Alberta waitlisted
2.8 NIU admitted
3.4 USI invitation for interview
3.9 CEU invitation for interview
3.10 WMU admitted with funding
考虑到funding,decline了ceu和usi
3.15 Calgary waitlisted
到目前为止只有一封funded offer…已经开始看wmu的课程syllabus和住宿信息了、、
3.22 Alberta admitted
3.24 终于收到了TTU的回信on the waitlist
3.25 McMaster rejected
3.26 TTU rejected 噗这是突然有很多人接了offer吗
4.3 declined Alberta
4.5 NIU admitted with GA…
4.8 withdrew from Calgary waitlist
4.12 declined WMU; accepted NIU
A really tough decision…给Charlie写最后的decline offer邮件忍不住哭出来了 本来已经决定接受WMU了但突然被告知Charlie要离开两年 没有办法指导学生

12 Likes

工作量尚可,我们系的要求是,每周TA工作时间在二十小时以内都是合理的,我个人经验是,通常可以在十小时以内完成工作。

2 Likes

谢谢分享!

请问你VT是收到拒信了吗 还是说没有offer你觉得应该是拒了

1 Like

我是发邮件问了Jordan Menzies(他们的graduate admissions director),然后她直接跟我说被拒了 :sob:

好的🥺

我也感觉自己太弱了 :sob:

1 Like

AOI: Epistemology, Metaphysics, History (Kant, Wittgenstein)
Johns Hopkins University BA in philosophy and cog sci, combined MA in philosophy
GPA:3.89
GRE:V167/Q170/AW4 (写作太烂了所以大部分学校没交)
Summer programs: PSP5, CMU 2021

Coursework:
Logic/Science: intro/decision game theory/Phil of general science/modal/set theory/spinoza with modal logic(audit)
LEMM: intro metaphysics/epistemology/metaphysics/skepticism(grad)/metametaphysics(grad)/animal mind
History: intro Greek/intro modern/Kant/Hegel/existentialism/Stoic Ethics(grad)/Wittgenstein
Value: Intro phil of race/death and dying/animal ethics

Writing Sample:
Personal Identity and Dream Skepticism
(BPhil字数原因交了一篇与AOI无关的:Beyond the Soul and Virtue: Benefit in Stoic Ethics)

Letter writers:
#1 Epistemology老师,上过四节课,包括一节grad seminar。grad seminar的期末作文后来发展成了writing sample。申请期间帮忙看过一次作文。
#2 Metaphysics老师,上过两节课,包括一节grad seminar。指导了我的independent study:发展上面提到的那篇作文成了writing sample。
#3 Logic老师,上过四节课,包括一节旁听。大三申请夏校时帮我写过一封,稍微update了一下。

Results:
A/W: UCI Phil, SASP MPhil, Oxford BPhil, Rochester (declined), ILLC Logic MSc (declined), Umass, Notre Dame , CMU (拒了PhD发了个MA, declined)
R(包括assumed): Toronto, Chicago, UTAustin, UCLA, UCSD, USC, Pitt Phil, Northwestern, UCB, MIT, Yale, UNC, Brown, NYU, Princeton, Harvard, Columbia, Cornell, Rutgers

主要在UCI和BPhil之间纠结,感觉跟去年的讨论差不多。Rochester我会再了解一下,目前感觉虽然有很多人做M&E,但因为没人做history,不如UCI更fit,估计会decline。希望大家能给些建议!

3.7 ND waitlist,BPhil基本被劝退,除非能有funding(据说每年一人)。
3.10 Declined Rochester.
4.11 Accepted UCI. Withdrew ND, UMass Waitlists. About to decline SASP and BPhil.

17 Likes

个人建议去UCI。首先UCI是很棒的项目;其次读BPhil增加了时间成本和经济成本……

3 Likes

谢谢你的建议!!我目前也是倾向于去UCI,BPhil的时间经济成本确实很高。

想问一下为什么打算拒掉曼大?

AOI: General Philosophy of Science, Metaphysics, Political Philosophy
GPA: 3.62/4.00(大一大二的成绩真的超级差😭,大四上学期的成绩是3.88)
No GRE score

Coursework:

History of Philosophy: Ancient Philosophy/ Early and Late Medieval Philosophy/ Early Analytic Philosophy/ Topics in Ancient Philosophy: Plato/ Topics in Medieval Philosophy: Aquinas

Logic/Science: Modern Symbolic Logic/ Intermediate Philosophy/ Puzzles and Paradox/ Advanced Seminar in Logic/ Philosophy of Natural Science/ Philosophy of Mathematics/ Philosophy of Physics/ Seminar in Philosophy of Science: AI and Value Alignment Problem/ Philosophy in the Age of Internet/ Philosophy for Scientists/

M&E: Seminar in Metaphysics: Ontology and Metaontology/ Seminar in Philosophy of Language: Reference Theory/ Seminar in Epistemology (in-progress)

Theory of Value: Political Philosophy/ Issues in Philosophy of Law/ Ethics: Death and Dying/ Ethics: Genetics and Reproduction

Writing Sample:
Against ‘Against Monism’
找教授和论坛里的青行灯老师都看过(在这里真的超级感谢教授和青行灯老师给我留的意见和评价);得到的反馈大多都是"not substantive"(这也很正常,毕竟只是一篇课上的term paper),可见WS质量不高。)
Brandeis因为可以交两篇,所以还提交了一篇AI Ethics相关的。

Letter Writers:
#1: Metaphysics的教授,上过一节seminar。
#2: Philosophy of Science的教授,上过一节三年级的课。
#3: Philosophy of Language的教授,上过一节seminar。
(因为大三结束的时候才确定想继续pursue philosophy professionally,大四才开始好好学习:sob:。所以所有的letter writers都是大四上学期课程的professors;而且全部都是今年1月份才和教授求的推荐信。教授们真的太好了:sob::heart:

Results:
A/W: NIU , UChicago , St. Andrews , KCL , SFSU , TTU , CEU , UW-Milwaukee (off the WL)
R: Brandeis
(Note: TTU是在2月15号左右才交的申请)

2.9 NIU admitted
3.4 UW-Milwaukee waitlisted (发邮件问了Miren Boehm, 她说"You are at the top. If the current positions in your area of interests become available, then you would be among the next in line.")
3.4 SFSU发邮件说才把我的application交到department for review
3.7 KCL admitted
3.8 SFSU admitted
3.16 TTU 终于进入department review了 :joy: :joy: :joy: (真的申请太晚了)
3.17 Brandeis rejected;问了原因,反馈是: 1. WS不够substantial 2. 某一篇letter打开来是空白的
3.19 CEU admitted with funding

总的来说,我的申请材料不算好(尤其是成绩和WS都不优秀),所以我猜测应该是教授们写的推荐信对我很有帮助。

7 Likes

已经拒掉啦,原因大概就是学制和funding。需要说的前提是我打算回国找工作,所以主要看论文发表数量,学校名气次之(当然,顶尖学校更好使,但我申不上)。英国学制3.5年,美国5年,看我的背景就可以理解我的哲学基础很差,我不认为我自己有马上开始写博士论文的能力,还是希望多修一些课夯实下基础。而且,英制的博士很看老师的具体情况,看老师能分给你多少时间和精力,都是不确定的。更重要的是,发一篇论文大概需要2年左右时间,去英国读书的话,3年确实有点紧。另外,如果我在uiuc开始写博士论文的时候,还对我现在这个博士选题感兴趣的话,我还可以申请去那边交流。当然,最重要的就是funding啦,我是国际生,能申的比较少,csc英国文科竞争很激烈(我是指中国方面,不是合作学校的提名,提名大于实际人数),而且5月份才出结果,风险还是很大的。

4 Likes